Home ›
Blog ›
HalloweenCostumes.com Review

HalloweenCostumes.com Review: Is It Legit? Price Match, Returns & Shipping

By Henry Walker • October 15, 2026

Is HalloweenCostumes.com legit? Our review covers price matching, Monster Rewards, free shipping over $65, the 18% restocking fee and how to save on your order.

HalloweenCostumes.com Review: Is It Legit? Price Match, Returns & Shipping

HalloweenCostumes.com is one of the biggest costume websites in the US, and every October a lot of shoppers ask the same question before ordering: is it legit, and is it actually a good place to buy? We looked at how the store works, from price matching and rewards to shipping and returns, so you know exactly what to expect before you pay. If you decide to order, check our HalloweenCostumes.com promo codes first for the offers that are live right now.

Is HalloweenCostumes.com Legit?

Yes. HalloweenCostumes.com is a real US retailer run by FUN.com, a company based in North Mankato, Minnesota. It has a public customer service phone line, a help center, secure checkout and well-known payment options such as PayPal and Apple Pay. It also ships worldwide and runs local versions of the site for Canada, the UK, Australia, Mexico and Europe. A scam site would not offer any of that.

The bigger question for most shoppers is not whether the store is real, but whether its rules suit them. The return policy in particular is stricter than many clothing stores, so read the section below before you order.

What You Can Buy at HalloweenCostumes.com

Adult and kids' costumes - men's, women's, plus-size, teen, toddler and baby costumes in classic, funny, scary and movie themes.
Licensed characters - officially licensed costumes from popular movies, TV shows, games and superheroes.
Exclusive house-brand costumes - the store designs and makes many of its own costumes, so you will find styles here that other shops do not carry.
Group and couple costumes - matching outfits for families, friends and office parties.
Pet costumes - outfits for small and large dogs and cats.
Accessories and makeup - wigs, masks, hats, props, face paint and special-effects makeup.
Halloween decorations - animatronics, yard props, inflatables and indoor decor.

How the HalloweenCostumes.com Price Match Works

This is one of the store's most useful features and one that many shoppers miss. If you find the exact same item for a lower price on another US website, HalloweenCostumes.com will match it. A few conditions apply:

The item must be the exact same product, new and in stock at the other store.
The other seller must be a US website. Marketplace sellers such as eBay do not count.
A price match cannot be combined with a promo code or any other discount.

So if a competitor has your costume a few dollars cheaper, compare two options: a price match, or the store's own promo code. Pick whichever brings the final total lower, because you cannot use both.

Monster Rewards: Is It Worth Joining?

Monster Rewards is the store's free loyalty program. Members earn points on their orders that turn into Monster Money for later purchases, and they also get birthday gifts and early access to sales. If you only buy one costume a year it will not save you much, but if you shop for a whole family, or come back for decorations and next year's outfits, it is free money for very little effort. Just sign in to your account before checkout so the points are counted.

Shipping: Costs and Timing

US orders over $65 qualify for free standard shipping. Below that amount you pay the shipping rate shown at checkout, so it is often worth adding a mask, wig or makeup kit to reach the free shipping minimum. International orders ship to more than 200 countries, but they take longer, so overseas shoppers should order early.

The most important tip is timing. October is peak season, and delivery slows down as Halloween gets close. Order at least two weeks before your party so you have time for an exchange if the size is wrong.

Return Policy: Read This Before You Order

HalloweenCostumes.com accepts returns that are postmarked within 30 days of the order date. Items should be unused and in their original condition. The key detail is the fee:

Refund to your original payment - an 18% restocking fee is taken from the refund.
Store credit - no restocking fee, so you get the full value back to spend on another item.

Because of this, store credit is usually the better choice if a costume does not fit and you still want something else. Try your costume on as soon as it arrives, and check the store's current return page for the latest rules before you send anything back.

How to Save Money at HalloweenCostumes.com

Start with a promo code. The store runs percentage-off and dollar-off codes during the Halloween season. It accepts one code per order, so test the current ones and keep the biggest saving.
Sign up for emails. New subscribers usually get a welcome coupon for 15% off the first order.
Use the price match. If another US store is cheaper, ask for a price match instead of a code.
Browse the sale and clearance pages. Discounts there often reach up to 90% off, though popular sizes sell out fast.
Reach the free shipping amount. Combine items into one order of $65 or more.
Join Monster Rewards. Points from this year's costume can pay for part of next year's.
Pay in smaller parts. Sezzle and PayPal Credit let you spread the cost of a bigger order.

Still comparing costume stores? Our Halloween 2026 savings guide lists the best stores for costumes, cosplay, makeup, decorations, candy and pet outfits in one place.

Pros and Cons of HalloweenCostumes.com

What we like:

Huge range, including exclusive house-brand costumes you will not find elsewhere.
Price matching against other US websites.
A free rewards program with birthday gifts and early sale access.
Worldwide shipping and many payment options.
Large sale and clearance sections.

Things to keep in mind:

An 18% restocking fee applies to refunds, though not to store credit.
Free shipping starts at $65, which is higher than some costume stores.
Only one promo code per order, and it cannot be combined with a price match.
Delivery gets slower in the last two weeks of October.

Our Verdict

HalloweenCostumes.com is a safe and reliable place to buy Halloween costumes, especially if you want a wide choice or a costume that only this store sells. Order early, check the size chart carefully because of the restocking fee, and always compare a promo code against the price match before you pay. Do that, and it is one of the better-value costume stores online.

HalloweenCostumes.com FAQs

Is HalloweenCostumes.com a real company?

Yes. It is run by FUN.com, an online retailer based in North Mankato, Minnesota, and it ships orders to customers in the US and more than 200 other countries.